Crypto Firm Triumphs: SEC Hit With $1.8 Million in Legal Costs Over Misconduct

In a decisive legal setback for the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), a federal judge has mandated that the agency pay $1.8 million in legal costs.

Judge Robert Shelby of the US District Court for the District of Utah made the decision.

Crypto Community Criticizes SEC After Its Legal Defeat

This order came after the SEC’s failed lawsuit against D.E.B.T. Box, a crypto firm it had accused of fraudulent practices.

The conflict began with the SEC’s July 2023 allegation that D.E.B.T. Box had illegally raised $50 million through unregistered securities sales. Consequently, the SEC froze the firm’s assets under an ex parte restraining order, issued without prior notice to the firm and based on what later emerged as misrepresented facts.

A pivotal March ruling highlighted the SEC’s “bad faith conduct,” criticizing the agency for its handling of the restraining order. As it turned out, D.E.B.T. Box contested the SEC’s claims, citing inaccuracies and leading to threats of sanctions against the SEC.

Read more: Who Is Gary Gensler? Everything To Know About the SEC Chairman

Moreover, Judge Shelby described the SEC’s misuse of power as “gross” and emphasized the necessity for regulatory accountability. The sanctions now compel the SEC to reimburse about $1 million for attorney fees and $750,000 for receiver fees. Given the SEC’s improper actions, the judge confirmed these expenses as necessary, dismissing the case without prejudice.

“Today’s decision is a monumental victory, not just for D.E.B.T. Box but for the entire industry and our dedicated community. It underscores the importance of integrity and fairness in regulatory practices,” the D.E.B.T. Box team wrote .

Despite an apology from SEC enforcement chief Gurbir Grewal regarding the oversight, Judge Shelby dismissed any requests to spare the SEC from sanctions . He insisted that the SEC’s actions were not just oversights but deliberate attempts to skew the legal proceedings against D.E.B.T. Box.

The financial repercussions of this case are significant, with the SEC’s fines funded by taxpayer money. This has incited considerable criticism within the crypto community and the general public, urging greater regulatory accountability and reform.

“This should be shocking to the American government. Political figures as high up as the President should be publicly up in arms about things like this. They should be demanding change and answers from Gary Gensler, but they won’t,” a crypto community member wrote .

Figures like Paul Grewal, Chief Legal Officer at Coinbase, and billionaire investor Mark Cuban have vocally criticized the SEC’s aggressive regulatory stance. Cuban has suggested that the SEC’s approach could impact political outcomes. He particularly highlighted the influence of crypto on younger and independent voters in the upcoming Presidential election .

Read more: Crypto Regulation: What Are the Benefits and Drawbacks?

Cuban believes that the future of crypto regulation should not remain under the SEC’s jurisdiction but should instead be managed by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).